Fresta's Italian American Cuisine - Sarasota, FL

Fresta's Italian American Cuisine in Sarasota

Philly Roots Run Deep at Our Table

Built by restaurant lifers with a family name on the door, Fresta’s brings old-school care and a distinctly Philadelphia point of view to Florida’s Gulf Coast. As an Italian-American restaurant in Sarasota and Bradenton, we lean into the details that define us: house-shaved ribeye with Cooper Sharp on seeded rolls, roasted pork, chicken cutlets, fresh pasta, and specialty pies. Even guests searching for pizza in Bradenton can find something with our character, backed by traditional recipes and quality ingredients. This is casual dining with family roots, Philly instincts, and plenty of reasons to return.

Italian Catering in Sarasota & Beyond

Big Plans Call for a Better Spread

Give the guest list something worth talking about. Baked lasagna layers fresh pasta with ricotta and marinara, while Short Rib Gemelli brings Parmesan cream and horseradish gremolata into the mix. For anyone chasing a cheesesteak in Bradenton or specialty pizza in Sarasota, the catering services offer plenty of ways to build a lineup around the occasion. Bring us your plans and we'll help shape the menu.

catering

Host Your Party with Us

Give the Occasion Somewhere to Come Alive

A birthday, graduation, or family reunion feels better when everyone can relax into the event. Our casual indoor and outdoor areas set the stage for conversation, laughter, and a few rounds around the table. If your crew already considers ours the best Philly cheesesteak in Sarasota, give them another reason to meet here. Get in touch and start planning your celebration.

book a party

Reserve Your Table Today

Your Seat Is Ready When You Are

Make room in your schedule for a proper sit-down meal. Settle indoors or take a seat outside, then explore a menu that moves well beyond the expected, including Italian sandwiches in Sarasota alongside pastas, pizzas, and house specialties. Add a cocktail, beer, or glass of wine and enjoy the visit at your own pace. Book ahead and make your next meal official.

book a table
previous slidenext slide
  • slideshow photo number 1

    Gnocchi, ravioli, and full-plate plans.

    catering
  • slideshow photo number 2

    Family-owned, recipes made from scratch.

    Menu
  • slideshow photo number 3

    Stone-fire pizza, pasta, and real care.

    orders

Join the Team

Bring Your Drive to the Kitchen

There's always room for people who take pride in doing things well. At Fresta's, an Italian restaurant in Sarasota, we value dependable teammates who stay curious, pitch in, and keep learning as they go. If that sounds like your kind of workplace, send us your application and introduce yourself.

jobs

Order Italian-American Favorites

Serving Both Sides of the Local Appetite

Skip the predictable picks. Go for Steak Frites Pizza with roasted garlic and truffle oil, or the Brothers Pie layered with Italian meats and finished with arugula and balsamic. Our stone fired pizza in Sarasota and Philly sandwiches in Bradenton searches lead to a menu with plenty of personality. Choose what catches your eye and order online.

Order now

Newsletter